The Finals Swaps Real Commentators for AI, Sparking Outrage

•0•0Comment iconComment iconComment iconComment icon

A since-removed video from The Finals replaced the commentators for the Grand Major qualifiers with Scotty and June, AI-controlled characters.

Writer image

Übersetzt vonEditorial

Writer image

Überarbeitet vonEditorial

Artikel bearbeiten

Embark Studios has come under fire after replacing the human commentators on a broadcast of The Finals with AI-generated commentators. The change appeared in a highlight video of the APAC region’s closed qualifiers for the Grand Major, the game’s official tournament. The video was posted on social media and later removed.

The video used Scotty and June, fictional characters from The Finals, to commentate on match highlights. The commentators who had originally worked on the broadcasts, including Proto, Kai, TheeHyperactive and Bluepanda, publicly reacted to the decision. Proto said the group had invested time, effort, passion and emotion into four qualifier cycles, only to be replaced by two AI commentators who even repeated phrases associated with the professionals.

Bluepanda also criticized the decision, saying that for nearly seven years, she had been told her work was valued before being ignored or informed that Embark was taking the talent team in a different direction.

The discussion spread to other competitive gaming communities. LemonKiwi, a commentator for Marvel Rivals, called the use of AI trained on the real commentators’ voices concerning and criticized the quality of the commentary. Fighting game commentator Damascus also questioned the practice, saying the professionals were being used without their knowledge or consent.

Some players linked the incident to the Dynamic Commentary feature announced for The Finals in October. The feature uses Scotty and June to mention players’ names and describe specific moments in matches based on the context of the action. The characters’ voices were recorded by human actors paid by Embark, but their lines are generated through text-to-speech conversion and an artificial intelligence model trained on those voices.

Asked to comment on the incident, Embark said it chose Scotty and June because players were familiar with them and to introduce The Finals’ competitive scene to a broader audience. The company also acknowledged that this was not the right direction given the work of the original commentators on the matches.

Wie hat Ihnen dieser Artikel gefallen?

0%
Nutzerwertung (0)

Teilen Sie diesen Artikel!